IOC Relaxes Trans Hormone Rules
Forum rules
It's such a fine line between stupid and clever. Random guest posting.
It's such a fine line between stupid and clever. Random guest posting.
- Black Orchid
- Posts: 25685
- Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 1:10 am
IOC Relaxes Trans Hormone Rules
Olympics bosses have just made it even easier for trans athletes to beat women.
The decision by the International Olympic Committee to scrap rules on hormone levels for male-born trans women athletes is bad news for elite female sports stars. It creates a shameful mismatch that makes a mockery of fair play.
Always first on the podium for self-congratulation, the IOC continues its quest to be a transgender champion at the expense of elite women athletes with newly announced guidelines that will prove another bodyblow to females in sport.
Somehow, while trumpeting its credentials as a standard bearer of human rights, the IOC totally ignores the hard-fought battle waged by women over the last 100 years just to be treated as equals, and allows trans women – who were born as men – to compete against them. Now that mismatch has been made even easier.
Rules governing the level of testosterone in an athlete’s body have been relaxed, and are now deemed “medically unnecessary” by the IOC. Athletes born as male – and let’s be honest, that is who this is largely about – no longer have to artificially reduce their testosterone levels in the run-up to competition.
Female-born athletes wishing to compete against men face no barriers either but can you name just one?
Read more
Iran women’s goalkeeper responds to accusations of being a man Iran women’s goalkeeper responds to accusations of being a man
The IOC rules had previously asked that transgender athletes wishing to compete as females should record testosterone levels below 10 nanomoles per litre for at least 12 months before their first competition. Even then, however, many scientists said the guidelines did little to mitigate the biological advantages of those who have gone through puberty as males, including bone and muscle density. Millennia of evolution can’t be dismissed.
This was an issue that affected Kiwi weightlifter Laurel Hubbard, 43, who became something of a trans poster person for this year’s Tokyo games having switched gender to compete in the +87kg women’s category. After all the hoo-ha and back-slapping, ironically Hubbard was a total flop, failing to record a single successful lift and has now quit the sport. Job done.
Not everyone bought the woke agenda here, with Belgian athlete Anna Vanbellinghen, who competed in the same category as Hubbard, labelling the Kiwi’s appearance “a bad joke.”
But that didn't stop the IOC claiming a gold medal for moral superiority for what was a very public but single instance of allowing a male-born athlete way past their best to compete against women.
Alongside Hubbard, there was also much fanfare for Canadian footballer Quinn, who while now identifying as a man was born female and plays in the Canadian women’s team. So lemme get this straight, an athlete who was born a woman competes as a woman. Err, somehow that’s progress?
You can see how the idiocy of trans thinking is not just unfair, it’s a humiliating slap in the face for those elite female-born athletes who have devoted their lives to excelling in the sporting arena, only to have genetics suddenly appear as a final hurdle when the finishing line seemed so close.
To even try to understand the cockeyed thinking here, you have to first accept the critical theory on gender, which the IOC has swallowed wholesale. And that is that a person’s sex as identified at birth is not fixed to their gender. That what’s between someone’s legs does not determine who they are, it’s what’s between their ears.
Women can become men who can become women. Despite the fact that scientifically this is almost impossible – there are some very rare intersex chromosomal disorders that might prove the exception – it is a woke view of the world that has crept into many walks of life, with elite sport being one of the more recent.
Interestingly, it must be said that this is something that appears largely in amateur sport, of which the Olympics is the biggest stage. Professional sport tends to prefer the more traditional, binary outlook. Why? Because it’s fairer. When trans woman Fallon Fox was pitted against Tamikka Brents in a mixed martial arts contest back in 2014, the outcome was more an attack than a competitive match.
Fox fractured her opponent’s skull before winning in a technical knockout. After the bout, Brents confessed, “I can only say that I have never felt so dominated in my life and that I am an abnormally strong woman in my own right.” That might be an extreme case, but that’s what can happen.
Certainly, the latest IOC guidelines do nothing to ensure that this sort of grossly unfair mismatch doesn’t become a more frequent spectacle at an elite sporting level. While professing to be all about fairness and inclusivity, in announcing their new rules today the ruling body of the Olympics has gone backwards with its acquiescence to the trans lobby.
Women’s rights have been sacrificed at the woke altar by the clueless, self-appointed guardians of morality in sport that sit on the IOC. Female athletes will rightly feel cheated, because this is a disgrace.
https://www.rt.com/op-ed/540569-ioc-oly ... -athletes/
I won't be watching any female competitions at the Olympics anymore. Not that I ever did lol.
The decision by the International Olympic Committee to scrap rules on hormone levels for male-born trans women athletes is bad news for elite female sports stars. It creates a shameful mismatch that makes a mockery of fair play.
Always first on the podium for self-congratulation, the IOC continues its quest to be a transgender champion at the expense of elite women athletes with newly announced guidelines that will prove another bodyblow to females in sport.
Somehow, while trumpeting its credentials as a standard bearer of human rights, the IOC totally ignores the hard-fought battle waged by women over the last 100 years just to be treated as equals, and allows trans women – who were born as men – to compete against them. Now that mismatch has been made even easier.
Rules governing the level of testosterone in an athlete’s body have been relaxed, and are now deemed “medically unnecessary” by the IOC. Athletes born as male – and let’s be honest, that is who this is largely about – no longer have to artificially reduce their testosterone levels in the run-up to competition.
Female-born athletes wishing to compete against men face no barriers either but can you name just one?
Read more
Iran women’s goalkeeper responds to accusations of being a man Iran women’s goalkeeper responds to accusations of being a man
The IOC rules had previously asked that transgender athletes wishing to compete as females should record testosterone levels below 10 nanomoles per litre for at least 12 months before their first competition. Even then, however, many scientists said the guidelines did little to mitigate the biological advantages of those who have gone through puberty as males, including bone and muscle density. Millennia of evolution can’t be dismissed.
This was an issue that affected Kiwi weightlifter Laurel Hubbard, 43, who became something of a trans poster person for this year’s Tokyo games having switched gender to compete in the +87kg women’s category. After all the hoo-ha and back-slapping, ironically Hubbard was a total flop, failing to record a single successful lift and has now quit the sport. Job done.
Not everyone bought the woke agenda here, with Belgian athlete Anna Vanbellinghen, who competed in the same category as Hubbard, labelling the Kiwi’s appearance “a bad joke.”
But that didn't stop the IOC claiming a gold medal for moral superiority for what was a very public but single instance of allowing a male-born athlete way past their best to compete against women.
Alongside Hubbard, there was also much fanfare for Canadian footballer Quinn, who while now identifying as a man was born female and plays in the Canadian women’s team. So lemme get this straight, an athlete who was born a woman competes as a woman. Err, somehow that’s progress?
You can see how the idiocy of trans thinking is not just unfair, it’s a humiliating slap in the face for those elite female-born athletes who have devoted their lives to excelling in the sporting arena, only to have genetics suddenly appear as a final hurdle when the finishing line seemed so close.
To even try to understand the cockeyed thinking here, you have to first accept the critical theory on gender, which the IOC has swallowed wholesale. And that is that a person’s sex as identified at birth is not fixed to their gender. That what’s between someone’s legs does not determine who they are, it’s what’s between their ears.
Women can become men who can become women. Despite the fact that scientifically this is almost impossible – there are some very rare intersex chromosomal disorders that might prove the exception – it is a woke view of the world that has crept into many walks of life, with elite sport being one of the more recent.
Interestingly, it must be said that this is something that appears largely in amateur sport, of which the Olympics is the biggest stage. Professional sport tends to prefer the more traditional, binary outlook. Why? Because it’s fairer. When trans woman Fallon Fox was pitted against Tamikka Brents in a mixed martial arts contest back in 2014, the outcome was more an attack than a competitive match.
Fox fractured her opponent’s skull before winning in a technical knockout. After the bout, Brents confessed, “I can only say that I have never felt so dominated in my life and that I am an abnormally strong woman in my own right.” That might be an extreme case, but that’s what can happen.
Certainly, the latest IOC guidelines do nothing to ensure that this sort of grossly unfair mismatch doesn’t become a more frequent spectacle at an elite sporting level. While professing to be all about fairness and inclusivity, in announcing their new rules today the ruling body of the Olympics has gone backwards with its acquiescence to the trans lobby.
Women’s rights have been sacrificed at the woke altar by the clueless, self-appointed guardians of morality in sport that sit on the IOC. Female athletes will rightly feel cheated, because this is a disgrace.
https://www.rt.com/op-ed/540569-ioc-oly ... -athletes/
I won't be watching any female competitions at the Olympics anymore. Not that I ever did lol.
-
- Posts: 132
- Joined: Thu Nov 25, 2021 10:45 am
Re: IOC Relaxes Trans Hormone Rules
Your point being what?Black Orchid wrote: ↑Sun Nov 28, 2021 10:26 am
I won't be watching any female competitions at the Olympics anymore. Not that I ever did lol.
-
- Posts: 132
- Joined: Thu Nov 25, 2021 10:45 am
Re: IOC Relaxes Trans Hormone Rules
And given that the hormone level rules were completely arbitrary and had no relationship to actual competition/science this is pretty much a transphobic rant.
- Black Orchid
- Posts: 25685
- Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 1:10 am
Re: IOC Relaxes Trans Hormone Rules
How very mysogynistic of you.
- Valkie
- Posts: 2662
- Joined: Sun Jul 29, 2018 4:07 pm
Re: IOC Relaxes Trans Hormone Rules
Oh well, there goes women's sports.
I have a dream
A world free from the plague of Islam
A world that has never known the horrors of the cult of death.
My hope is that in time, Islam will be nothing but a bad dream
A world free from the plague of Islam
A world that has never known the horrors of the cult of death.
My hope is that in time, Islam will be nothing but a bad dream
-
- Posts: 132
- Joined: Thu Nov 25, 2021 10:45 am
- Bogan
- Posts: 948
- Joined: Sat Aug 24, 2019 5:27 pm
Re: IOC Relaxes Trans Hormone Rules
Winston Churchill once wrote that every noble organisation set up to advance the human condition would eventually go rotten. I think he meant that it was only a matter of time before the high minded idealists were replaced by the careerists, the fundamentalists, the power mad, and those who know how to game the system.
The women's "Liberation" movement has now gone this way.
Once set up to advance female equality and women's rights, it has been usurped by left wing activists who have made it into a parody of what it was first set up to be. Whoda thunk that a movement set up to advance female equality and women's rights would give a free pass to Islam? Or that it would morph into advocating "transgender" rights to the extent that it now pushes for biological males who would like to be females, to compete against real females in female sporting events?
The only good thing about what has happened is that a new generation of young women are beginning to understand how stupid the left wing activists really are, and they are getting angry about them. This will make them re think every left wing cause the loony left activists push.
The women's "Liberation" movement has now gone this way.
Once set up to advance female equality and women's rights, it has been usurped by left wing activists who have made it into a parody of what it was first set up to be. Whoda thunk that a movement set up to advance female equality and women's rights would give a free pass to Islam? Or that it would morph into advocating "transgender" rights to the extent that it now pushes for biological males who would like to be females, to compete against real females in female sporting events?
The only good thing about what has happened is that a new generation of young women are beginning to understand how stupid the left wing activists really are, and they are getting angry about them. This will make them re think every left wing cause the loony left activists push.
- Black Orchid
- Posts: 25685
- Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 1:10 am
Re: IOC Relaxes Trans Hormone Rules
Lia Thomas, a 22-year old transgender swimmer at the University of Pennsylvania, has been shattering women’s records at the school.
Before her transition, she competed for three years at Penn as a man, named Will Thomas.
At a meet including Princeton and Cornell on Nov. 20, Thomas had a 1:43:47 time in the 200-meter freestyle and 4:35:06 in the 500-meter freestyle.
These times were records for Penn and would have placed Thomas second and third, respectively, in the NCAA Women’s Championships, according to the website OutKick.
It is unknown when Thomas transitioned from male to female, but the swimmer competed as a man as recently as November 2019. NCAA rules mandate at least one year of testosterone suppression treatment to be eligible to compete as a woman.
https://www.news.com.au/sport/sports-li ... 312772ddeb
Only the mentally inept can support and/or try to justify this.
Before her transition, she competed for three years at Penn as a man, named Will Thomas.
At a meet including Princeton and Cornell on Nov. 20, Thomas had a 1:43:47 time in the 200-meter freestyle and 4:35:06 in the 500-meter freestyle.
These times were records for Penn and would have placed Thomas second and third, respectively, in the NCAA Women’s Championships, according to the website OutKick.
It is unknown when Thomas transitioned from male to female, but the swimmer competed as a man as recently as November 2019. NCAA rules mandate at least one year of testosterone suppression treatment to be eligible to compete as a woman.
https://www.news.com.au/sport/sports-li ... 312772ddeb
Only the mentally inept can support and/or try to justify this.
-
- Posts: 132
- Joined: Thu Nov 25, 2021 10:45 am
Re: IOC Relaxes Trans Hormone Rules
So essentially what you're saying is that with all these advantages she still wouldn't have won the NCAA chamionships.
- Bogan
- Posts: 948
- Joined: Sat Aug 24, 2019 5:27 pm
Re: IOC Relaxes Trans Hormone Rules
Sporting research and statistics over decades has consistently shown that males have a 10% performance advantage over females.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 16 guests