What do you think about Sparta?

[Bobby]

I am going to open up your points and anyone else's ideas to discussion.
Do you think it's correct for me to set rules in concrete here?
So far I agree with your 7 points.
Does anyone else agree?

The only thing which has changed since you said that is that ONE person only, disagreed.

If I recall correctly, you were livid in your criticism of Monk when he did not do what he said he would do after he won the election against "Mellie." Are you breaking your word like you accused Monk of doing?

I don't remember that.
It must have been a long time ago.

Only last year or so. Monk v Jasin to be Mod of Cats and Critters.

I didn't know Mellie was JaSin.
You're not spreading false rumors are you?

My criticism of Monk referred to his banning of so many members from his MRB
after he promised to ban no one.
I got banned over nothing from his forum.
Nef. was banned when she hadn't even posted there!

[Aussie]

JaSin posted/bragged that he was Mellie. He made a very long post explaining it all.

The point is....you were livid with Monk for not keeping his word about bannings. That is the relevant point to this discussion.

Also of interest, you keep asking me to comment on your pros and cons, yet you ignore the fact that NO-ONE else has addressed them either.

[Bobby]

JaSin posted/bragged that he was Mellie. He made a very long post explaining it all.

The point is....you were livid with Monk for not keeping his word about bannings. That is the relevant point to this discussion.

Also of interest, you keep asking me to comment on your pros and cons, yet you ignore the fact that NO-ONE else has addressed them either.

I don't know if I would believe JaSin.
He told many fibs.

I don't know if I was livid with Monk?
I solved the problem of his banning me by starting a cats and critters thread
in my Environment MRB.

Good point about the PROS & CONS.
Could others please chime in?

[Neferti]

JaSin posted/bragged that he was Mellie. He made a very long post explaining it all.

The point is....you were livid with Monk for not keeping his word about bannings. That is the relevant point to this discussion.

Also of interest, you keep asking me to comment on your pros and cons, yet you ignore the fact that NO-ONE else has addressed them either.

That all? Just a pissy little MRB at OzPol, via a POLL and lots of socks. I thought you meant a REAL Election at PA.

[Aussie]

JaSin posted/bragged that he was Mellie. He made a very long post explaining it all.

The point is....you were livid with Monk for not keeping his word about bannings. That is the relevant point to this discussion.

Also of interest, you keep asking me to comment on your pros and cons, yet you ignore the fact that NO-ONE else has addressed them either.

That all? Just a pissy little MRB at OzPol, via a POLL and lots of socks. I thought you meant a REAL Election at PA.

Yes....and when the socks were rooted out by Vic, Mellie/JaSin lost the lead he had.

[Neferti]

JaSin posted/bragged that he was Mellie. He made a very long post explaining it all.

The point is....you were livid with Monk for not keeping his word about bannings. That is the relevant point to this discussion.

Also of interest, you keep asking me to comment on your pros and cons, yet you ignore the fact that NO-ONE else has addressed them either.

That all? Just a pissy little MRB at OzPol, via a POLL and lots of socks. I thought you meant a REAL Election at PA.

Yes....and when the socks were rooted out by Vic, Mellie/JaSin lost the lead he had.

I didn't even vote in it and I rarely vote in those Polls anyway. Waste of time and energy.

[Black Orchid]

I am going to open up your points and anyone else's ideas to discussion.
Do you think it's correct for me to set rules in concrete here?
So far I agree with your 7 points.
Does anyone else agree?

The only thing which has changed since you said that is that ONE person only, disagreed.

If I recall correctly, you were livid in your criticism of Monk when he did not do what he said he would do after he won the election against "Mellie." Are you breaking your word like you accused Monk of doing?

I don't remember that.
It must have been a long time ago.

Only last year or so. Monk v Jasin to be Mod of Cats and Critters.

I didn't know Mellie was JaSin.
You're not spreading false rumors are you?

My criticism of Monk referred to his banning of so many members from his MRB
after he promised to ban no one.
I got banned over nothing from his forum.
Nef. was banned when she hadn't even posted there!

He's not. He said it as a joke!

[Aussie]

So...when was he lying? When he made that very long post explaining in great detail that he was Mellie, or when he said he was just joking?

[Bobby]

I didn't know Mellie was JaSin.
You're not spreading false rumors are you?

My criticism of Monk referred to his banning of so many members from his MRB
after he promised to ban no one.
I got banned over nothing from his forum.
Nef. was banned when she hadn't even posted there!

He's not. He said it as a joke!

So - is Aussie spreading false rumors?

[Neferti]

So...when was he lying? When he made that very long post explaining in great detail that he was Mellie, or when he said he was just joking?

I think it was probably more a "come in spinner" and you, Arsie, came in hook, line and sinker because you disliked Mellie.