Semenya is banned

[sprintcyclist]

I am in two minds about Caster Semenya. S/he is probably one of these rare freaks of nature and the sex verification test results were never released but s/he clearly identifies as a man.

To the best of my knowledge it was born with the underdeveloped sexual organs of both male and female, I guess they would classically be classed as hermaphrodite

If that is the case, then they have to compete in the higher class. ie, against men

[BigP]

I am in two minds about Caster Semenya. S/he is probably one of these rare freaks of nature and the sex verification test results were never released but s/he clearly identifies as a man.

To the best of my knowledge it was born with the underdeveloped sexual organs of both male and female, I guess they would classically be classed as hermaphrodite

If that is the case, then they have to compete in the higher class. ie, against men

Im not without a little sympathy for Semayna, but he is male, he could become a world class cheese roller, no problem with sex there .

[cods]

when you see the finish of any female race h/she takes part in it becomes pretty obvious no born female will ever touch h/her..

she could in fact beat many males out there....

in the past or even today... if a male wanted to be female they would take female hormones....

I would say looking at Semenya this isnt the case....she doesnt want the boobs and round hips...

and if her testosterone levels are higher than any female...... well therein lies the answer

she is in fact more male than female...

[sprintcyclist]

when you see the finish of any female race h/she takes part in it becomes pretty obvious no born female will ever touch h/her..

she could in fact beat many males out there....

in the past or even today... if a male wanted to be female they would take female hormones....

I would say looking at Semenya this isnt the case....she doesnt want the boobs and round hips...

and if her testosterone levels are higher than any female...... well therein lies the answer

she is in fact more male than female...

' ............... if a male wanted to be female they would take female hormones.... '
Sure, but they still can't compete against women.

[cods]

thats not the point I am making sprint.... women have never had to face this kind of competition before...

now with all our PC....it has become and issue....

imagine if someone like her wants to compete in the swimming pool...gymnastics...what about tennis?

it will never be a level playing field......when Semenya goes to her grave she will still have the physic of a male...


does she use female toilets...and change rooms.....?

[sprintcyclist]

thats not the point I am making sprint.... women have never had to face this kind of competition before...

now with all our PC....it has become and issue....

imagine if someone like her wants to compete in the swimming pool...gymnastics...what about tennis?

it will never be a level playing field......when Semenya goes to her grave she will still have the physic of a male...


does she use female toilets...and change rooms.....?

' ...... does she use female toilets...and change rooms..... '

That did cross my mind.
Does she use mens toilets or change rooms?

many of the mens change rooms at beaches are ... just one big open room. It's all in the open there is no hiding.
So, I stopped thinking about it

[Black Orchid]

Maybe all future competitions will just have to be run naked

[Neferti]

Maybe all future competitions will just have to be run naked

NO!!!! Remember Matt Shirvington in his lycra outfit!

[sprintcyclist]

Was thinking of wrestling, there may be some new methods of pinning your opponent to the floor

the phrase 'a sore loser' takes on a new aspect.

[Black Orchid]

Not sure I could cope with naked wrestling